Eleanor Roosevelt: The Girl Nobody Expected to Matter

Anna Eleanor Roosevelt was born into a world that expected very little from her. The year was 1884, and wealthy families like the Roosevelts had clear rules about what their daughters should become: pretty, quiet, and useful for making good marriages. Eleanor broke every single one of these rules.

Her childhood was a series of losses that would have crushed most people. Her mother died when Eleanor was eight, calling her “Granny” because the girl seemed too serious for a child. Her father, an alcoholic, died when she was ten after jumping from a window during a mental breakdown. Her younger brother died of the same disease that killed their mother. By age ten, Eleanor had lost almost everyone who mattered to her.

Most wealthy girls in her situation would have disappeared into the background, raised by relatives to be proper and unremarkable. Eleanor’s grandmother took her in, but something different happened at Allenswood Academy in London when Eleanor was fifteen. The headmistress, Marie Souvestre, saw something in this awkward American girl that others had missed.

Souvestre was exactly the kind of woman who terrified traditional families. She was French, unmarried, and believed that girls should think for themselves instead of just preparing for marriage. She spoke multiple languages, traveled the world, and had strong opinions about politics. Under her influence, Eleanor learned to speak fluent French, gained confidence, and discovered that her mind was actually quite sharp.

When Eleanor returned to New York at seventeen for her society debut, she was miserable. The whole point of these events was to help wealthy girls find husbands, but Eleanor felt like an outsider. She was tall, awkward, and serious in a world that valued small, pretty, and cheerful. Instead of giving up, she did something unexpected: she started working with poor families on the Lower East Side of Manhattan.

This was not what wealthy young women were supposed to do. Teaching dance and exercise to poor children was considered dangerous and inappropriate. But Eleanor discovered something important about herself: she was good at helping people, and she liked work that actually mattered.

Marriage as Political Partnership

In 1902, Eleanor encountered Franklin Roosevelt on a train. He was her fifth cousin, handsome, charming, and from an even more prominent family branch. Their courtship and marriage looked perfect from the outside, but the reality was far more complicated.

Franklin’s mother, Sara, controlled every aspect of their early marriage. She bought them a house connected to her own by sliding doors. She decorated it, staffed it, and ran it according to her preferences. Eleanor felt like a guest in her own home. Sara even told Eleanor’s children that she was more their mother than Eleanor was.

The marriage took another hit in 1918 when Eleanor discovered love letters from Franklin’s secretary, Lucy Mercer. Franklin had been having an affair, and he considered leaving Eleanor for the younger woman. Only pressure from his political advisors and threats from his mother to cut off his inheritance kept him in the marriage.

This betrayal could have destroyed Eleanor, but instead it freed her. She realized that she didn’t have to live her life according to other people’s expectations. If Franklin wanted to pursue his political career with a wife who looked good at public events, fine. But Eleanor was going to find her own purpose and her own power.

She started working with the Women’s Trade Union League, fighting for better working conditions, shorter hours, and fair wages for working women. She became active in Democratic Party politics, not just as Franklin’s wife but as a leader in her own right. When Franklin was diagnosed with polio in 1921 and couldn’t walk, Eleanor became his legs, traveling around New York state to inspect conditions and report back to him.

This partnership worked because both Eleanor and Franklin were ambitious people who cared more about accomplishing important things than about having a traditional marriage. They supported each other’s goals even when their personal relationship remained complicated.

Redefining What a First Lady Could Do

When Franklin became president in 1933, Eleanor was horrified. Previous first ladies had been expected to stay in the background, host parties, and smile at their husbands’ sides. Eleanor thought this was a waste of time and talent. The country was in the middle of the Great Depression, and millions of people needed help. She was not going to spend four years arranging flowers and posing for photographs.

Instead, Eleanor did something that shocked everyone: she held her own press conferences. No first lady had ever done this. She invited only female reporters, which forced newspapers to hire women to cover her. She started writing a daily newspaper column called “My Day” that reached millions of readers. She hosted her own radio show. She traveled constantly, visiting coal mines, unemployment lines, and relief centers to see conditions for herself.

Traditional politicians and journalists thought she was overstepping her role. They called her pushy, inappropriate, and too involved in politics. Eleanor didn’t care. She had discovered that being first lady gave her a platform to reach people who were suffering, and she was going to use that platform whether anyone liked it or not.

Her approach to racial equality was particularly controversial. She invited African American leaders to the White House for meals and meetings, which horrified many white Americans. When the Daughters of the American Revolution refused to let African American singer Marian Anderson perform at Constitution Hall, Eleanor resigned her membership and helped arrange for Anderson to sing at the Lincoln Memorial instead.

She also tried to include African Americans in New Deal programs, fighting against discrimination that kept Black workers from getting fair treatment. This made her extremely unpopular in the South, where rumors spread about “Eleanor Clubs” of Black domestic workers supposedly plotting against their white employers.

The Arthurdale Experiment

One of Eleanor’s most ambitious projects was Arthurdale, a planned community in West Virginia for unemployed coal miners and their families. In 1933, she visited mining families who had been blacklisted for union activities and were living in terrible conditions. Instead of just feeling sorry for them, Eleanor decided to do something about it.

Her idea was to create a new kind of community where families could support themselves through subsistence farming, handicrafts, and small manufacturing. The government would provide modern houses with electricity and indoor plumbing. Families would pay back the cost over thirty years and gradually become self-sufficient.

The project faced criticism from both conservatives and liberals. Conservatives called it socialist and a waste of taxpayer money. Some liberals thought it was paternalistic and didn’t address the real causes of unemployment. Eleanor kept pushing forward anyway, using her own money and raising funds from wealthy friends.

Arthurdale ultimately failed as an economic model. The community never became self-sufficient, and the government lost money on the investment. But for the families who lived there, it represented hope and dignity during a desperate time. Eleanor considered it a success because it proved that government could improve people’s lives when it tried.

The criticism of Arthurdale revealed something important about how people viewed Eleanor’s activism. When men proposed large-scale economic programs, they were considered serious policy leaders. When Eleanor proposed the same kinds of programs, she was called naive and sentimental. This double standard would follow her throughout her public career.

Hidden Relationships and Private Life

Eleanor’s personal life was far more complex than most people knew at the time. Her marriage to Franklin had become a political partnership rather than a romantic relationship after his affair with Lucy Mercer. Both Eleanor and Franklin developed close relationships with other people while maintaining their public marriage.

Eleanor’s relationship with journalist Lorena Hickok was particularly intense. They wrote to each other almost daily, and their letters contained language that suggested deep emotional and possibly physical intimacy. Eleanor wrote things like “I want to put my arms around you and kiss you at the corner of your mouth.”

Whether their relationship was sexual remains debated by historians, but it was clearly the most important emotional connection in Eleanor’s adult life. Hickok eventually gave up her journalism career to work for the Roosevelt administration, which compromised her professional independence but allowed her to be closer to Eleanor.

Eleanor also had close relationships with several other women, including Nancy Cook and Marion Dickerman, who were partners themselves. She built a cottage at Val-Kill on the Roosevelt property where she could spend time with these friends away from Franklin and his family.

In the 1930s, Eleanor also developed a friendship with Earl Miller, a New York state trooper assigned as her bodyguard. Miller was younger than Eleanor and taught her to ride horses, shoot guns, and drive cars. Their relationship scandalized some people, but it gave Eleanor a sense of adventure and physical confidence she had never experienced.

These relationships revealed Eleanor’s ability to create chosen family when her biological family disappointed her. She surrounded herself with people who supported her goals and understood her need for independence, even when those relationships didn’t fit conventional expectations.

Wartime Leadership and Moral Courage

World War II tested Eleanor’s principles and influence in new ways. She supported the war effort while trying to make sure it didn’t destroy civil liberties and social progress at home. This balancing act put her at odds with people on both sides of various issues.

When the government began interning Japanese Americans after Pearl Harbor, Eleanor spoke out against the policy. She wrote that “great hysteria against minority groups” was dangerous and unworthy of American values. This position was extremely unpopular, and newspapers called for her to be “forced to retire from public life.”

Eleanor also pushed for women to be included in war production jobs, arguing that the country needed all available workers. She visited factories, military bases, and hospitals to boost morale and assess conditions. Her trips to the South Pacific war zone were criticized as publicity stunts, but military leaders said her visits did more to improve troop morale than any other civilian effort.

At home, she co-chaired the Office of Civilian Defense, trying to prepare communities for possible attacks while maintaining democratic values. She clashed with other officials who wanted to focus only on military preparations while she insisted that social programs were also important for national defense.

Throughout the war, Eleanor maintained her focus on civil rights and social justice even when these concerns seemed secondary to military victory. She understood that the war would be meaningless if America won while abandoning the values that made victory worthwhile.

Creating the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

After Franklin died in 1945, many people expected Eleanor to retire from public life. She was sixty-one years old, had spent twelve years as first lady, and had earned the right to rest. Instead, she took on what would become her most important work: helping to create international human rights standards.

President Harry Truman appointed Eleanor as the American delegate to the United Nations. She became the first chairperson of the UN Commission on Human Rights, responsible for drafting what would become the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

This work required skills that Eleanor had developed over decades of political activity. She had to negotiate with delegates from dozens of countries with different political systems, religious traditions, and cultural values. She had to find language that everyone could accept while maintaining principles that actually meant something.

The process took three years and involved intense debates about fundamental questions: What rights should all human beings have? How could these rights be protected? What should happen when governments violated them? Eleanor led these discussions with patience, determination, and shrewd political judgment.

When the Declaration was finally adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 10, 1948, Eleanor received a standing ovation. The document established principles that would guide human rights movements for decades. It declared that all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights, regardless of race, religion, nationality, or political beliefs.

The Declaration didn’t have the force of law, but it provided a standard that activists and governments could use to challenge oppression. Eleanor called it “the international Magna Carta of all men everywhere.”

Media Pioneer and Cultural Influencer

Eleanor’s use of media was revolutionary for a political figure, especially a woman. She understood that reaching ordinary people required bypassing traditional gatekeepers who might filter or distort her message.

Her daily newspaper column “My Day” ran from 1936 until her death in 1962, reaching millions of readers. Unlike typical political commentary, the column mixed personal observations with policy discussions, making serious issues accessible to people who might not otherwise pay attention to politics.

Eleanor also embraced radio and television when these technologies were still new. She hosted her own radio programs, appeared as a guest on popular shows, and eventually had her own television program. She was one of the first political figures to understand that electronic media could create direct relationships with audiences.

Her media appearances were carefully planned to support her political goals. When she appeared on television with products she endorsed, she used the opportunity to discuss social issues. When she hosted shows about international affairs, she educated viewers about global problems they might not encounter elsewhere.

This media strategy allowed Eleanor to maintain influence even after she was no longer first lady. She remained one of the most recognized and trusted public figures in America throughout the 1950s, largely because of her direct communication with ordinary citizens.

Fighting the Conservative Backlash

The 1950s brought new challenges as conservative politicians and activists targeted the liberal programs Eleanor had supported. Senator Joseph McCarthy’s anti-communist campaigns included attacks on Eleanor and many of her associates.

Eleanor refused to be intimidated by these attacks. When conservative groups tried to link her to communist organizations, she responded with detailed factual rebuttals. When they criticized her international work as unpatriotic, she explained why human rights served American interests.

Her response to McCarthyism revealed her deep understanding of democratic values. She didn’t just defend herself; she defended the principle that Americans should be able to hold unpopular opinions without being destroyed professionally or personally.

Eleanor also fought against the revival of traditional gender roles that characterized the 1950s. While popular culture promoted the idea that women should focus exclusively on domestic life, Eleanor continued to argue that women had obligations to participate in public affairs.

She supported the early civil rights movement even when it was controversial among white liberals. She endorsed integration efforts, supported voting rights campaigns, and used her influence to pressure politicians who wanted to avoid racial issues.

International Elder Stateswoman

In her final years, Eleanor became a kind of unofficial American ambassador to the world. Foreign leaders sought her opinions, and international organizations requested her participation in important meetings.

She traveled extensively, visiting countries throughout Europe, Asia, and Latin America. These trips weren’t just ceremonial; Eleanor used them to learn about conditions in other countries and to promote American values abroad.

Her international reputation was based on her work with human rights, but it also reflected her ability to represent the best aspects of American democracy. Foreign audiences saw her as someone who embodied the ideals America claimed to support.

In 1961, President Kennedy appointed Eleanor to chair the Commission on the Status of Women, bringing her expertise to bear on questions about women’s equality that were becoming increasingly important.

Legacy of Transformation

Eleanor Roosevelt died on November 7, 1962, at age seventy-eight. Her funeral was attended by presidents, foreign leaders, and ordinary citizens who felt they had lost a personal advocate.

Her most obvious legacy was the transformation of the role of first lady. No woman in that position could ever again be expected to remain silent and decorative. Eleanor had shown that the platform came with responsibilities as well as privileges.

More importantly, Eleanor demonstrated that women could wield political power effectively without abandoning their concerns about social justice and human welfare. She proved that “women’s issues” like poverty, education, and civil rights were actually central to good governance.

Her approach to leadership emphasized building coalitions, communicating directly with affected communities, and maintaining focus on practical results rather than abstract principles. These methods influenced subsequent generations of activists and politicians.

The institutions Eleanor helped create, especially the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, continue to provide frameworks for protecting human dignity around the world. Her vision of international cooperation based on shared values remains relevant even as the specific challenges change.

The Woman Who Refused to Stay Silent

Eleanor Roosevelt’s story is ultimately about the power of refusing to accept limitations that others try to impose. She was told to be quiet, stay in the background, and defer to men who supposedly knew better. Instead, she used every platform available to her to speak for people who had no voice in the political process.

She transformed personal pain into public purpose, using her own experiences of loss and disappointment to understand what other people needed. She built a career around the radical idea that government should actually help citizens rather than just maintain order.

Most importantly, Eleanor showed that individual women could change the world when they refused to accept that their concerns didn’t matter. Her example continues to inspire people who believe that political power should be used to protect the vulnerable rather than privilege the powerful.

In a world where women’s political participation was barely tolerated, Eleanor Roosevelt made herself impossible to ignore. She proved that democracy works better when it includes everyone, and she spent her life making sure that principle became reality rather than just a nice idea.

Explore Related Stories

Scroll to Top